Wednesday, November 27, 2019

Indian Removal DBQ Google Docs free essay sample

Andrew Jackson wanted to protect the Indians from harm by relocating them n an area farther away from the United States. In Alexis De Discotheques Democracy in America, he states that the United States were, sincerely desirous of saving the remnant of the natives, and of maintaining them in the free possession of that territory which the Union has guaranteed to them. eke Jackson most of the states wanted to save the last of the natives. On the other hand, there were some that thought that they were barbaric and a threat to the states.So, the government had to side with the opposing states to exterminate some of the barbaric tribes [Document A]. Jackson wanted to rote the Cherokees from being exterminated so he started trying to convince them to relocate farther away. Lewis Sacs agreed with Jackson and Alexis saying that the Cherokees were, A barbarous people, depending for subsistence upon the scanty and precarious supplies furnished by the chase, cannot live in contact with a civilized community. We will write a custom essay sample on Indian Removal DBQ Google Docs or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page He believed that the Cherokees were barbaric and primitive people and they did not deserve to live in contact and get support from the Union [Document E]. Jackson did not exactly Moss 2 agree with this. He wanted the Indians removed, but that was because he anted to save them not discard them. The map in [Document F] shows where the lands of the Indians was before they were removed, where they were relocated to, and the routes the took to get from their lands to the reservations, including the Trail of Tears. Jacksons decision also had great opposition from some groups.Some Christian missionaries were against Jacksons efforts to remove the Indians. They thought that, the Cherokees are in a course Of improvement, which promises, if uninterrupted, to place them at no distant period, nearly on a level with their white brethren. They thought that the Cherokees were improving just as we were and would soon be like us, opposite of what Lewis thought [Document E]. In addition, since they would be prosperous without removal and are not a real threat, they should be left where they are [Document C]. Jackson believed that they would prosper just as well farther away and would be safe from disease and starvation. The Cherokees were also against being moved. In their memorial of the Cherokee nation, they say, We wish to remain in the land of our fathers. They did not want to have to leave the land that they have lived in for so long and they believed, in accordance with their treaties with the union, they had the right to remain in their lands [Document D].Jackson believed that although it was illegal, the Cherokees should be relocated because it is in their best interests even though they do not know. In Worcester v Georgia in 1832, it was settled that the Cherokees, the weaker state, should not have to surrender itself to a more powerful nation in order to gain protection, but they could live under the protection of the more powerful state while retaining their right of government and territory in the set boundaries [Document B].Jackson understood that they deserved to keep thei r government, but he thought that the well being of the Indians was more important than keeping to the rights and treaties of the Indians. Moss 3 It was not until 1 838, after Jackson had left office, that the U. S. Army forced 1 5,000 Cherokees to leave Georgia. The hardships on the Trail of Tears were so great that over 4,000 Cherokees died on their westward journey to the reservations. In conclusion, Jackson had other viable decisions he could have made, but he made his choice because he thought it was best for the Indians safety and welfare.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.